Click here to receive your FREE subscription to Campus Technology
Opinion
Semantic Search: Could the Web Think?
7/16/2008
|
|
Results from a Current Web Search
On the current Web, I did a quick search posing as someone who knows nothing about gardening and is searching for reasons either to try, or not to try, a garden. So, I typed in "Should I grow a garden?" and received a lot of links about what I should grow in my garden. In other words, my responses were begging the question.
So, I tried "Why should I grow a garden?" For this query, I got links that ignored the "why" in my query. Again, I found tips about growing a garden as if I'd already decided to garden actually knew a fair amount about soil testing and my local extension agent. My gardening novice persona still had no answer.
Then I tried "Benefits of growing a garden." The results told me "You get fresh vegetables," or "You are doing good for the planet," and "You can find peace while hoeing your garden." Still not really the answers I was looking for.
Finally, I tried "Reasons not to garden." My responses: "Five reasons not to move to New Jersey," and "Reasons not to own a cat," and "Reasons not to hate winter." (These examples are all taken from real search results!)
This was going nowhere. I didn't know how to ask the right question (using advanced search only showed that my specific question is not answered anywhere on the Web).
Somehow I would have had to guess the particular terms and phrases someone might have used in a paper or posting that would help me decide if I wanted to put any effort into learning about gardening. Finding the meaning I needed would be a long process given the current state of search.
To Search Semantically, You Need Ontologized Content
Of course, it's not just the search engines that are failing my gardening novice persona. The Web now grabs anything that is posted to it, no matter how the resource is rhetorically organized. So, it's really no surprise that from this grab bag of millions of potential links I didn't find a single match to the meaning of my query. No matter how smart the search engine, it can't do a good job searching uncharacterized and undefined content.
Recommended Reading
- Digital Arrays for Evidence-Based Learning
Our culture is redefining itself and we are redefining how we see learning. It is time for educators to get out of the box of seat time, finally, and consider evidence-based learning.
- 'That Which Weaves Together': The NSF Cyberlearning Report
Trent Batson takes a look at the National Science Foundation's Report of the NSF Task Force on Cyberlearning, "Fostering Learning in the Networked World: The Cyberlearning Opportunity and Challenge."
- The Power of Wikis in Higher Ed
Over the last six years, Stewart Mader has staked his career on the power of wikis. Mader first worked on wiki adoption initiatives in the IT department at Brown University, becoming fascinated by their power and potential. In this first half of a two-part interview, Mader talks about powerful ways to use wikis in education, content ownership issues, and how wikis tend to be used--and why.
- Sakai 2.5.2 Gets Performance Boost; New Modules Released
The Sakai Foundation has released the Sakai Collaboration and Learning Environment 2.5.2, the first maintenance update to the open-source learning management system since the 2.5 release in March. The new version includes performance enhancements, as well as a number of bug fixes and other enhancements.
- Microsoft Changes Virtualization Licensing Rules
Microsoft has made substantial changes to its virtualization licensing program, changes that will lower the cost of using virtualization for many customers.
- Vorex Upgrades Web-based Data Collection Tool for Schools
Vorex has released an update to its Vorex Online Survey, a Web-based data collection tool designed to allow schools to collect information and gather feedback from education stakeholders.
